Question
“You have three features and one quarter of engineering time. How do you decide what to build?”
Weak answer
I would talk to stakeholders and see what is most important to the business, then check what engineering thinks is feasible. Probably I would start with the one that has the biggest impact on revenue, since that is what the company cares about most this year.
Strong answer
I would score all three on RICE. Checkout retry: reach is 40,000 monthly checkout sessions, impact 2 because it removes a hard failure, confidence 90% because we have the funnel data, effort 1.5 person-months. That scores about 48,000. Referral widget: reach 6,000, impact 3, confidence 50% since we have never shipped referral here, effort 3. That scores 3,000. Admin bulk editor: reach 300 internal users, impact 3, confidence 100%, effort 0.5. That scores 1,800. Checkout retry ships first, by an order of magnitude. I would also flag that the referral score is dominated by that 50% confidence, so a two-week fake-door test buys more than another debate would.
Why the strong version wins: The strong answer treats Impact as a relative score and Confidence as a real discount, so a high-reach guess cannot outrank a sure thing, and it closes by naming what would change the ranking. The weak answer picks the winner first and reasons backwards to justify it.