Ghost job signal

Employer size band: where research finds the highest rates

This signal would fire for employers of 1,001 to 5,000 people, the band with the highest ghost rate in the research. It needs the employer's size, which we do not collect yet, so today this check does not run.

What the signal is

The rule reads the employer's size band and fires only for the 1,001 to 5,000 band. Without a size band it is reported as not evaluable and leaves the calculation.

Why it points to a ghost posting

Hunter Ng's analysis of Glassdoor interview reviews (arXiv, 2024) found the highest ghost rate, about 25 percent, at employers of 1,001 to 5,000 people: large enough for postings to get lost, not large enough for strict requisition control.

When a real vacancy trips it

It is a statement about a population. Any individual employer in the band may run its postings perfectly.

How to check it yourself

There is no per-posting check for a population rate. Use the facts instead: is the posting still on the employer's own board, and how long has it been there?

Run every check at once

Paste a posting or its link. We run all 25 signals that apply, show the words that triggered each, and list the checks we could not run.

Check a posting

Browser extension

Check LinkedIn and Indeed postings without pasting anything

The JobMentis extension for Chrome shows posting health beside the job you are reading on LinkedIn, Indeed, Glassdoor and the careers sites of 31 applicant tracking systems. It is free, with a free JobMentis account.

See the extension
  • It reads the page inside your own browser, so it works on the sites this web tool cannot fetch.
  • It dates the posting from the first time we recorded it, not from the date the board reset when the role was reposted.
  • One click saves the job to your tracker, and we keep re-checking it so you hear when it is taken down or quietly re-listed.

Other signals in this tier