Ghost job signal

Sector with a high ghost rate

This signal fires when the employer's sector is one the research puts well above the base rate: IT, software and technology, wholesale, construction and staffing. It is a prior about the sector, never a statement about the employer.

What the signal is

We read the employer's industry where it is supplied and match it against the list. When no industry is supplied the check is reported as not evaluable and leaves the calculation.

Why it points to a ghost posting

Hunter Ng (arXiv, 2024) found higher ghost rates in IT and specialised sectors, and a Clarify Capital survey of hiring managers pointed to wholesale and construction. Staffing firms post roles to collect candidates for several clients.

When a real vacancy trips it

Most postings in these sectors are real. A sector prior shifts the starting point a little, which is why it sits in the capped tier.

How to check it yourself

There is no per-posting check for a sector rate. Check the facts about this posting: its age and whether it is on the employer's own board.

Run every check at once

Paste a posting or its link. We run all 25 signals that apply, show the words that triggered each, and list the checks we could not run.

Check a posting

Browser extension

Check LinkedIn and Indeed postings without pasting anything

The JobMentis extension for Chrome shows posting health beside the job you are reading on LinkedIn, Indeed, Glassdoor and the careers sites of 31 applicant tracking systems. It is free, with a free JobMentis account.

See the extension
  • It reads the page inside your own browser, so it works on the sites this web tool cannot fetch.
  • It dates the posting from the first time we recorded it, not from the date the board reset when the role was reposted.
  • One click saves the job to your tracker, and we keep re-checking it so you hear when it is taken down or quietly re-listed.

Other signals in this tier